If you belong to a Protestant church, its teaching on the Lord’s Supper probably traces back to one of three sixteenth-century Reformers: Martin Luther, Huldrych Zwingli, or John Calvin. It may surprise you how differently they read the same words of Jesus. Each deserves to be heard in his own terms.
Martin Luther: “This is my body”
Luther (1483–1546) rejected the Mass as a sacrifice and the medieval term transubstantiation. But he held firmly that Christ’s true body and blood are present in the Supper. His Small Catechism of 1529, still taught in Lutheran churches, answers the question “What is the Sacrament of the Altar?” this way:
It is the true body and blood of our Lord Jesus Christ, under the bread and wine, for us Christians to eat and to drink, instituted by Christ Himself.
Martin Luther, Small Catechism, “The Sacrament of the Altar” (Triglot Concordia translation)
The Augsburg Confession of 1530 likewise teaches that “the Body and Blood of Christ are truly present, and are distributed to those who eat the Supper of the Lord” (Article X).
Lutherans call this a sacramental union. The bread remains bread, and Christ’s true body is present “under the bread, with the bread, in the bread” (Formula of Concord, Solid Declaration VII.35), often summarized as “in, with, and under.” Lutherans generally reject the label “consubstantiation” that others sometimes give their view. For Luther, the decisive point was simple. Jesus said is, and His word must be believed even when reason objects.
Huldrych Zwingli: “is” means “signifies”
Zwingli (1484–1531), the reformer of Zürich, came to the opposite conclusion. He argued that in “This is my body,” the word is means signifies. He pointed to Exodus 12:11, where the lamb is called “Yahweh’s Passover”: the lamb was not the Lord’s passing over, but its sign. The bread represents Christ’s body, which since the Ascension is in heaven at the Father’s right hand.
For Zwingli, John 6:63, “The flesh profits nothing,” was a key text: what saves is faith in Christ crucified, not physical eating. He did not deny that Christ is present among His gathered people, only that Christ’s body is present in the bread. The Supper, for him, is a memorial in which the church gives thanks for Christ’s death and publicly pledges itself as His people.
Many Baptist, Pentecostal, and nondenominational churches hold a memorial view close to Zwingli’s, often calling the Supper an “ordinance” rather than a sacrament.
Marburg, 1529
In October 1529, Landgrave Philip of Hesse brought Luther, Zwingli, and their colleagues to his castle at Marburg, hoping to unite the Protestant cause. The theologians drew up fifteen articles and agreed on the first fourteen, including the Trinity, the person of Christ, justification by faith, and baptism. On the fifteenth, the Lord’s Supper, they agreed in part. But they could not agree on whether Christ’s true body and blood are bodily present in the bread and wine.
According to the accounts, Luther chalked the words Hoc est corpus meum, “This is my body,” on the table and kept returning to them. The two sides parted without sharing communion.
Marburg shows that the question isn’t simply Catholics versus Protestants. The Reformers themselves, reading the same Bible with the same commitment to Scripture, could not agree on what Jesus meant.
John Calvin: a real, spiritual presence
John Calvin (1509–1564), a generation later in Geneva, sought a path between Luther and Zwingli. He rejected transubstantiation, and he rejected Luther’s teaching that Christ’s body is present in the bread, because Christ’s body is in heaven. But against a bare memorial, he insisted that in the Supper believers truly feed on Christ’s body and blood, because the Holy Spirit unites them to Him:
Therefore, what our mind does not comprehend let faith conceive—viz. that the Spirit truly unites things separated by space.
John Calvin, Institutes of the Christian Religion IV.17.10 (Beveridge translation)
Christ seals this communion in the Supper, he wrote, “not by presenting a vain or empty sign.” And with real humility he admitted:
Now, should any one ask me as to the mode, I will not be ashamed to confess that it is too high a mystery either for my mind to comprehend or my words to express; and to speak more plainly, I rather feel than understand it.
John Calvin, Institutes IV.17.32
Presbyterian and Reformed churches carry on Calvin’s view, often called “real spiritual presence.”
Anglicans and Methodists
The Church of England’s Thirty-Nine Articles reject transubstantiation but teach that “The body of Christ is given, taken, and eaten in the Supper, only after an heavenly and spiritual manner” (Article XXVIII). That language is close to Calvin’s. In practice, Anglicans have held a wide range of views. Some evangelicals stand near Zwingli or Calvin. Anglo-Catholics believe the bread and wine truly become Christ’s body and blood, and many adore Him in the reserved Sacrament.
Methodists inherited a shortened form of the Anglican articles through John Wesley, and the Wesleys’ Hymns on the Lord’s Supper (1745) speak warmly of Christ’s presence at His table. Methodist churches today generally affirm that Christ is really present while leaving the manner a mystery.
How the Catholic and Orthodox view differs
Catholics agree with Luther that is means is. They agree with Calvin that the Holy Spirit is at work and that the mystery surpasses our understanding. But they go further than either.
- A change, not only a presence. Catholics believe that at the consecration the whole substance of the bread and wine is changed into the body and blood of Christ, while the appearances of bread and wine remain. The Church calls this change transubstantiation (CCC 1376).
- The whole Christ. What is present is not a part of Christ but Christ Himself, “the body and blood, together with the soul and divinity” (CCC 1374).
- A lasting presence. Christ remains present as long as the appearances of bread and wine remain (CCC 1377). That is why Catholics keep the Sacrament in the tabernacle and worship Him there. The lamp burning beside it is the one this site is named for.
- One sacrifice. The Mass makes present Christ’s one sacrifice on the cross. It is not a new or additional sacrifice (CCC 1366–1367). The next chapter says more about this.
The Eastern Orthodox churches likewise believe the bread and wine are truly changed into Christ’s body and blood. Many Orthodox prefer to leave the manner of the change a mystery rather than adopt the Latin term, though some Orthodox councils have used an equivalent Greek word, metousiōsis.
Lutherans also believe in a real, objective presence, but most tie it to the eating and drinking rather than to a presence that continues afterward. Calvin placed the presence in the believer’s Spirit-given communion with Christ in heaven. Zwingli saw a memorial of an absent body. These are real differences, held in good faith by sincere Christians. Naming them honestly is the first step toward understanding one another.
Going further
- Common objections, answered charitably: the last chapter on this path
- What the first Christians believed: the witnesses all the Reformers appealed to
- Find a chapel near you: see the reserved Sacrament for yourself
Scripture quotations are from the World English Bible (public domain) unless otherwise noted. References marked “CCC” are to the Catechism of the Catholic Church.