If you want to know what a teacher meant, it helps to ask his students. Some of the earliest Christian writers had heard the apostles, or the apostles’ own disciples, in person. How did they understand “This is my body”?
These writers are not Scripture, and Catholics don’t treat them as infallible. But they are witnesses to what the Church believed in its first centuries, long before the medieval debates.
Ignatius of Antioch (about 107)
Ignatius was bishop of Antioch, the city where “the disciples were first called Christians” (Acts 11:26). Ancient tradition holds that he had known the apostles themselves. Around the year 107, under the emperor Trajan, he was arrested and taken to Rome to die in the arena. On the way he wrote seven letters to churches. He was writing within living memory of the apostles.
One of his concerns was a group, later called Docetists, who taught that Christ only seemed to have a human body. Writing to the church at Smyrna, Ignatius describes them:
They abstain from the Eucharist and from prayer, because they confess not the Eucharist to be the flesh of our Saviour Jesus Christ, which suffered for our sins, and which the Father, of His goodness, raised up again.
Ignatius of Antioch, Letter to the Smyrnaeans 7
Ignatius doesn’t argue for the Real Presence. He assumes it as the Church’s shared faith and uses it to expose the heretics. Those who deny that Christ came in real flesh can’t accept that the Eucharist is His flesh. For Ignatius, the Incarnation and the Eucharist stand or fall together.
To the Christians of Rome, as he faced martyrdom, he wrote: “I desire the bread of God, the heavenly bread, the bread of life, which is the flesh of Jesus Christ” (Letter to the Romans 7).
Justin Martyr (about 155)
Justin was a philosopher who became a Christian and was martyred in Rome around 165. In about 155 he wrote a defense of the faith addressed to the emperor Antoninus Pius. Pagans had heard strange rumors about Christian gatherings, so Justin simply explained what Christians do on Sunday. His account is one of the earliest descriptions of Christian worship we have (First Apology 65–67).
For not as common bread and common drink do we receive these; but in like manner as Jesus Christ our Saviour, having been made flesh by the Word of God, had both flesh and blood for our salvation, so likewise have we been taught that the food which is blessed by the prayer of His word, and from which our blood and flesh by transmutation are nourished, is the flesh and blood of that Jesus who was made flesh.
Justin Martyr, First Apology 66
This isn’t a debate with other Christians. It is a plain explanation, for outsiders, of what Christians believe. The blessed bread and wine are received “not as common bread,” but as the flesh and blood of Jesus, and Justin says this is what Christians “have been taught.”
Irenaeus of Lyons (about 180)
Irenaeus grew up in Asia Minor, where as a boy he listened to Polycarp of Smyrna, who had known the apostle John. Later he became bishop of Lyons in Gaul. Around 180 he wrote Against Heresies, aimed at Gnostic teachers who despised the material world and denied the resurrection of the body.
His argument, too, assumes that the Eucharist is Christ’s body and blood:
For as the bread, which is produced from the earth, when it receives the invocation of God, is no longer common bread, but the Eucharist, consisting of two realities, earthly and heavenly; so also our bodies, when they receive the Eucharist, are no longer corruptible, having the hope of the resurrection to eternity.
Irenaeus, Against Heresies IV.18.5
Elsewhere he describes the grain of wheat that, made into bread and “having received the Word of God, becomes the Eucharist, which is the body and blood of Christ” (Against Heresies V.2.3). How, he asks, can anyone say our flesh can’t receive eternal life, when it is “nourished from the body and blood of the Lord”?
Cyril of Jerusalem (about 350)
In the mid-fourth century, the bishop of Jerusalem gave talks to the newly baptized during Easter week, explaining the sacraments they had just received. These Mystagogical Catecheses are traditionally credited to St. Cyril. Some scholars think they may come from his successor, John. Either way, they show how the church of Jerusalem taught the faith.
Since then He Himself declared and said of the Bread, This is My Body, who shall dare to doubt any longer? And since He has Himself affirmed and said, This is My Blood, who shall ever hesitate, saying, that it is not His blood?
Cyril of Jerusalem, Mystagogical Catechesis IV.1
He goes on: “Judge not the matter from the taste, but from faith be fully assured without misgiving, that the Body and Blood of Christ have been vouchsafed to you” (IV.6). He also speaks of a change. The Church prays for God to send the Holy Spirit to “make the Bread the Body of Christ, and the Wine the Blood of Christ; for whatsoever the Holy Ghost has touched, is surely sanctified and changed” (V.7).
He even taught the newly baptized to “make your left hand a throne for the right, as for that which is to receive a King” (V.21).
An honest note
Not every early writer used the same vocabulary, and Christians have read some of them differently. Cyril himself says that “in the figure of Bread is given to you His Body” (IV.3), and other early writers call the bread and wine “figures,” “types,” or “symbols.” St. Augustine (354–430) is the most debated case. He could tell his hearers, “Believe, and you have eaten already” (Tractates on John 25.12). In a sermon on the Psalms that turns to John 6, he paraphrased Jesus as saying, “you are not to eat this body which you see,” and said the mystery “must be spiritually understood.” Many Protestant scholars, following Calvin, read Augustine as teaching a spiritual rather than a bodily presence. Catholic scholars answer that for the Fathers a “figure” was not an empty sign but one that truly contained what it signified. They point out that in the very same sermon Augustine said Christ “gave that very flesh to us to eat for our salvation; and no one eats that flesh, unless he has first worshipped” (Exposition on Psalm 99, 8). Readers can weigh this for themselves.
What is hard to find in the early centuries is anyone teaching that the Eucharist is only bread that reminds us of Christ.
One faith in many places
These witnesses wrote from Syria, Asia Minor, Rome, Gaul, and Palestine, for different audiences. Yet they say the same thing: the blessed bread and cup are the flesh and blood of Christ. And they say it not as a new idea but as what the Church had received.
Going further
- Luther, Calvin, and Zwingli: the next chapter on this path
- St. Paul and the church at Corinth: the Scripture these writers were reading
- The Church Fathers at New Advent: read these letters and sermons in full, free online
Scripture quotations are from the World English Bible (public domain) unless otherwise noted. References marked “CCC” are to the Catechism of the Catholic Church.