I'm a Christian, but not Catholic · Part 6

Common objections, answered charitably

Seven honest questions Christians often raise about the Real Presence, with a Catholic answer to each, and an invitation.

If you’ve read this far, objections have probably been forming as you went. That’s good. Sincere Christians have asked these seven questions for centuries, and they deserve real answers, not slogans.

1. “Jesus also said ‘I am the door’ and ‘I am the vine’”

He did, and no one thinks He is made of wood or grows grapes. Jesus often spoke in images (John 8:12; 10:9; 15:5). So why take “This is my body” literally?

Catholics agree that Jesus used metaphors. The question is how to tell when He did. In John 10 and 15, no one is confused and no one leaves. In John 6, His hearers took Him literally and objected, and Jesus repeated Himself more strongly until many disciples walked away (John 6:52–66). Elsewhere in Scripture, eating someone’s flesh as a figure of speech meant attacking them (Psalm 27:2; Micah 3:3), so a purely figurative reading of John 6 would be a strange figure indeed. And at the Supper, Jesus wasn’t comparing Himself to something. He took bread and said what it was.

2. “Jesus said, ‘Do this in remembrance of me’”

He did (Luke 22:19; 1 Corinthians 11:24–25; the World English Bible reads “in memory of me”). Catholics agree that the Eucharist is a memorial. But in Scripture, a memorial is more than recalling. Passover was “a memorial” (Exodus 12:14) that made the Exodus present to each new generation. The Greek word in Jesus’ command, anamnēsis, is used in the Greek Old Testament for memorials offered before God in worship (Numbers 10:10; Leviticus 24:7). The Catechism says the biblical memorial “is not merely the recollection of past events” (CCC 1363). Remembering and real presence aren’t opposites. More in The Last Supper.

3. “The flesh profits nothing”

This verse (John 6:63) deserves care. But Jesus says “the flesh,” not “my flesh.” He has just said His flesh is given “for the life of the world” (6:51), so it can’t be worthless. In John, “flesh” set against “spirit” usually means human nature left to itself (John 3:6; 8:15). Jesus is telling the grumbling disciples that natural reasoning can’t grasp His words; only the faith the Father gives can (6:64–65). And after verse 63 the disciples still leave (6:66), which would be strange if He had just told them it was only a metaphor. More in John 6.

4. “Hebrews says Christ was sacrificed once for all”

Catholics believe it wholeheartedly. Christ “entered in once for all into the Holy Place, having obtained eternal redemption” (Hebrews 9:12), and “by one offering he has perfected forever those who are being sanctified” (Hebrews 10:14).

The Church does not teach that Christ is sacrificed again at each Mass, or that the Mass adds to Calvary. It teaches that the Mass re-presents, makes present, the one sacrifice of the cross (CCC 1366). In the Catechism’s words, the sacrifice of Christ and the sacrifice of the Eucharist “are one single sacrifice”; “only the manner of offering is different” (CCC 1367).

Christ’s sacrifice happened once in history, but it is not over and gone: He “lives forever to make intercession” (Hebrews 7:25), and John sees in heaven “a Lamb standing, as though it had been slain” (Revelation 5:6). The Mass doesn’t repeat Calvary. It brings us to it. The Didache, a very early church manual, already calls the Sunday Eucharist a “sacrifice” and links it with Malachi 1:11 (Didache 14).

5. “Drinking blood is forbidden”

It was, strictly. God forbade eating flesh with its blood (Genesis 9:4). The Law said, “the life of the flesh is in the blood” (Leviticus 17:11), and forbade eating it (Leviticus 17:10–14). The council in Jerusalem asked Gentile believers to abstain from blood (Acts 15:20, 29).

That is exactly why John 6 shocked its first hearers, and Jesus refused to soften it. Notice the reason for the law: the life is in the blood, and the blood was reserved to God for atonement. In the Eucharist we don’t receive an animal’s life. We receive the life of the Son of God, given so that we may share it: “he who feeds on me will also live because of me” (John 6:57). And Paul, who carried the Jerusalem decree to the churches (Acts 16:4), still called the cup “a sharing of the blood of Christ” (1 Corinthians 10:16).

6. “This sounds like cannibalism”

Cannibalism would be abhorrent, and it isn’t what the Church teaches. Cannibals eat the dead flesh of a human being in its natural form, and the victim is harmed or destroyed. In the Eucharist, Christ is present living and glorified, whole and entire, under the appearances of bread and wine. He isn’t cut into pieces or diminished: “the breaking of the bread does not divide Christ” (CCC 1377). We don’t take His life. He gives us His life.

Second-century pagans actually accused Christians of “Thyestean feasts,” after a figure in Greek myth tricked into eating his own sons (Athenagoras, A Plea for the Christians 3, about 177). Many historians think the rumor grew out of Christians’ own language about eating the body and drinking the blood of the Lord.

7. “Isn’t this a medieval invention?”

The word transubstantiation is medieval. It appears in theologians of the eleventh and twelfth centuries and was adopted by the Fourth Lateran Council in 1215. The Council of Trent later used it to name the change of the whole substance of bread and wine into Christ’s body and blood (CCC 1376).

But the belief the word describes is far older. As we saw in What the first Christians believed, Ignatius, Justin, Irenaeus, and Cyril all call the Eucharist the flesh and blood of Christ. The Church’s language grew more precise over time, as it did with the Trinity, but the faith wasn’t invented.

History adds a witness. The Oriental Orthodox churches (Coptic, Armenian, Ethiopian, Syriac) separated from the rest of the Church in the fifth century. The Eastern Orthodox separated from Rome in the eleventh. Both believe the bread and wine truly become the body and blood of Christ. A medieval Latin invention would not explain why churches long separated from Rome share the same faith.

An invitation

None of these answers will settle every question, and you don’t have to settle them all today. Christians who love Jesus have disagreed about His Supper for five hundred years, and those disagreements are worth holding with humility and charity on every side.

But if something on this path has stirred in you, whether curiosity or longing or a question you can’t put down, we invite you to come and see. Visit a Catholic Mass and watch what happens at the consecration. You are welcome. Because Communion expresses a unity of faith, non-Catholics usually don’t receive, but you can pray in your pew, and in many parishes you may come forward with your arms crossed for a blessing. Or sit quietly in an Adoration chapel, where Catholics keep watch before the Blessed Sacrament, and speak to Jesus honestly. Catholics believe He is there, waiting for you.

Scripture quotations are from the World English Bible (public domain) unless otherwise noted. References marked “CCC” are to the Catechism of the Catholic Church.

Other starting points

Something on your mind that this doesn’t answer? Ask us privately.