I'm a Christian, but not Catholic · Part 3

St. Paul and the church at Corinth

Paul’s first letter to Corinth gives us the earliest written account of the Lord’s Supper. His warnings about receiving it are some of the strongest words in the New Testament.

Paul wrote his first letter to the Corinthians around AD 53 to 55, probably before any of the Gospels were written down. That makes his words about the Lord’s Supper the earliest written account of it we have.

He wasn’t writing a treatise on the sacraments. He mentioned the Supper because the church at Corinth had problems. The way he corrects them tells us a great deal about what he believed.

“A sharing of the blood of Christ”

In chapter 10, Paul warns the Corinthians against joining in pagan sacrificial meals. His argument rests on the Lord’s Supper:

The cup of blessing which we bless, isn’t it a sharing of the blood of Christ? The bread which we break, isn’t it a sharing of the body of Christ? Because there is one loaf of bread, we, who are many, are one body; for we all partake of the one loaf of bread.

1 Corinthians 10:16–17

The word translated “sharing” is koinōnia. Older English Bibles render it “communion”; others say “participation.” It is the word the New Testament uses for the deepest kind of fellowship. Paul’s questions expect the answer yes: the cup is a real participation in Christ’s blood, and the bread in His body.

Then Paul makes a comparison:

Consider Israel according to the flesh. Don’t those who eat the sacrifices participate in the altar? … You can’t both drink the cup of the Lord and the cup of demons. You can’t both partake of the table of the Lord and of the table of demons.

1 Corinthians 10:18, 21

Paul sets the Lord’s table beside Israel’s altar and the pagan altars. In each case, eating brings you into communion with what was offered. That is why the Corinthians can’t do both.

Verse 17 matters too. Because we share one bread, we become one body. For Paul, the body of Christ received at the table and the body of Christ that is the Church belong together. We’ll come back to that.

What Paul received from the Lord

In chapter 11 the problem is different. When the Corinthians gathered for the Lord’s Supper, the well-off ate and drank their fill while poorer members went hungry (1 Corinthians 11:20–22). Paul answers by reminding them what the Supper is:

For I received from the Lord that which also I delivered to you, that the Lord Jesus on the night in which he was betrayed took bread. When he had given thanks, he broke it and said, “Take, eat. This is my body, which is broken for you. Do this in memory of me.” In the same way he also took the cup after supper, saying, “This cup is the new covenant in my blood. Do this, as often as you drink, in memory of me.” For as often as you eat this bread and drink this cup, you proclaim the Lord’s death until he comes.

1 Corinthians 11:23–26

“Received” and “delivered” are the words used for handing on a sacred tradition. Paul uses the same pair for the Gospel itself in 1 Corinthians 15:3. He isn’t offering his own opinion. He is passing on what was entrusted to him.

“Guilty of the body and the blood”

Then come the warnings:

Therefore whoever eats this bread or drinks the Lord’s cup in a way unworthy of the Lord will be guilty of the body and the blood of the Lord. But let a man examine himself, and so let him eat of the bread and drink of the cup. For he who eats and drinks in an unworthy way eats and drinks judgment to himself if he doesn’t discern the Lord’s body. For this cause many among you are weak and sickly, and not a few sleep.

1 Corinthians 11:27–30

These are remarkable words. Receiving unworthily doesn’t just show disrespect for a reminder of Christ. It makes a person “guilty of the body and the blood of the Lord.” Failing to “discern” the body brings judgment. And Paul ties this to real consequences: some in Corinth have fallen ill, and some have died. (“Sleep” is Paul’s usual word for the death of believers.)

How should we read this?

Christians who hold a memorial view take these verses seriously too. On their reading, the Corinthians’ sin was treating a holy ordinance carelessly and shaming the poor at the very meal that proclaims Christ’s death. To “discern the body,” many argue, is to recognize the church as Christ’s body. The context of divisions (11:18) and the words of 10:17 make that a reasonable reading. Several of the oldest manuscripts of verse 29 read simply “the body,” not “the Lord’s body.” And God does discipline His people when they dishonor what is holy.

Catholics don’t think we have to choose between the Church and the Sacrament here. Paul himself joined them in 10:16–17: one bread, one body. But Catholics do want to ask a question, respectfully.

If the bread and cup are only symbols, what does it mean to be “guilty of the body and the blood of the Lord”? We can dishonor a symbol. But Paul speaks of guilt against the Lord’s own body and blood, and the consequence he describes is not just a rebuke but sickness and death. These warnings make the most natural sense if what is eaten really is what Paul calls it.

That is how the earliest Christians after Paul read him, as we’ll see in the next chapter.

Paul and John together

It is worth noticing how Paul and John fit together. John records Jesus’ promise:

He who eats my flesh and drinks my blood lives in me, and I in him.

John 6:56

Paul describes the result in the life of a real church: a koinōnia, a communion, in the body and blood of Christ that makes many people into one body. Neither writer sounds as if he is describing a mere reminder.

Paul also shows us the right response. He doesn’t tell the Corinthians to stay away from the Lord’s table. He tells them to examine themselves, to wait for one another, and to come with reverence (11:28, 33). That is still the Catholic practice. It is why Catholics go to Confession before receiving if they are aware of serious sin, and why they keep a short fast before Communion.

Going further

Scripture quotations are from the World English Bible (public domain) unless otherwise noted. References marked “CCC” are to the Catechism of the Catholic Church.

Other starting points

Something on your mind that this doesn’t answer? Ask us privately.