What happened
On the eve of the Assumption in 1730, while much of Siena was at the cathedral for the city’s traditional offering of candles, thieves broke into the Franciscan church of San Francesco. They forced open the tabernacle and took a ciborium holding about 350 recently consecrated Hosts. The theft was discovered at Mass the next morning, August 15, and Archbishop Alessandro Zondadari ordered public prayer and fasting in reparation.
On August 17 the Hosts were found in the offering box of the nearby church of Santa Maria in Provenzano, among coins, dust, and cobwebs. After Church authorities verified them, they were carried back to San Francesco in procession. For reasons the records do not make clear, the friars never consumed them.
What was examined
The Archdiocese of Siena has published the record of these examinations:
- 1780. On a visitation, the Franciscan minister general found about 230 Hosts, whole and in pieces, wrapped in a corporal in a wooden box.
- 1789. Archbishop Tiberio Borghesi examined them and found them firm and fresh-looking. He also had some unconsecrated hosts kept separately for comparison. The archdiocese reports that these were later found completely spoiled.
- 1799. A commission found the Hosts firm and glossy, without odor, and of good taste, with a slight staleness.
- 1815 and 1854. Further inspections. In 1854 Archbishop Giuseppe Mancini and two other priests consumed one Host and some fragments, and found the rest unchanged since 1799.
- 1914. On June 10, under Archbishop Prospero Scaccia, a team of University of Siena professors that included the chemist Siro Grimaldi confirmed that the Hosts were made of wheat flour and found them well preserved. Grimaldi noted that the container’s seal had partly come loose and that mold had grown on the inside of its glass lid, but not on the Hosts. The findings were presented at the International Eucharistic Congress in Lourdes that July.
- 1922, 1950, and 1952. Further checks when the Hosts were moved to new monstrances. On August 6, 1951, thieves stole the monstrance but left the Hosts in the tabernacle.
- 2014. On September 10, with the approval of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, Archbishop Antonio Buoncristiani opened the container again. Researchers from Italy’s National Research Council ran non-invasive tests on sample Hosts, including inspection under a digital microscope, a test for microbial activity, and cultures that showed no microbial growth after 7 or 14 days. The official record counted 225 Hosts plus 13 fragments, and noted far more microbes on the container than on the Host that was swabbed.
What the Church has said
The archdiocese calls the Hosts a Eucharistic prodigy and has long promoted their veneration. Pope John Paul II spoke of their significance when he visited Siena in 1980. For a diocesan Eucharistic Year in 2014–15, Pope Francis granted a plenary indulgence to those who came to adore them. As far as we can find, the Church has made no formal declaration that their preservation is miraculous.
Questions that remain
What would ordinary wafers do? The case rests on the claim that unleavened wafers kept this way should have spoiled within a few years. The 1789 comparison is the only control on record, and we know it only from the archdiocese’s brief summary, which says the unconsecrated hosts were kept in the same place and conditions but gives no further detail. Molds and bacteria need moisture to grow, so dryness and storage matter a great deal. No modern, long-term controlled comparison has been published.
Who examined them. Every examination was ordered by Church authorities, though university professors took part in 1914 and researchers from a state research council in 2014. The 2014 tests documented the Hosts’ condition and the absence of contamination without trying to explain it; the researchers’ summary speaks simply of good conservation after 284 years.
Handling and counts. The Hosts have been handled many times. Some were eaten in 1854, and in 1914 commission members received one of the old Hosts in Communion and reported the taste of coarse wheat flour. After the 1951 theft, police dusted them for fingerprints, and they were cleaned one by one with a feather. Counts have varied: about 350 in 1730, about 230 in 1780, 224 in 1922, and 225 plus fragments in 2014. Other published figures include 223 and 233. The records we consulted do not explain the drop between 1730 and 1780.
What believers point to. In 1914 Grimaldi found mold growing on glass while the bread beside it, which mold normally favors, stayed clean. He wrote that he would leave the explanation to unbelievers and confine himself to recording the fact. In 2014, nearly three centuries after the theft, cultures taken from a sample Host grew nothing at all.
Visiting today
The Hosts are kept in the Basilica of San Francesco in Siena. According to Tuscany’s regional tourism site, they are displayed for veneration on the 17th of each month, the anniversary of their recovery. Check with the basilica before you go.
Sources and further reading
- La storia del Prodigio Eucaristico — Archdiocese of Siena–Colle di Val d'Elsa–Montalcino, notes by Archbishop Antonio Buoncristiani (Italian). The history of the Hosts and the dated record of each examination, with extracts from the 1914 report.
- Ricognizione al prodigio eucaristico delle SS. Particole conservate nella Basilica di San Francesco in Siena: Verbale — Archdiocese of Siena, official record of the examination of September 10, 2014 (Italian).
- Ricognizione Sacre Particole 2014 — Archdiocese of Siena, press release of October 24, 2014 (Italian). Summary of the 2014 test results.
- Diagnostic analysis of Sacred Hosts from the basilica of San Francesco (Siena) through a multi-disciplinary approach — Cristiano Riminesi and others, National Research Council of Italy (CNR), conference paper, 2016. The researchers' own summary of the 2014 tests.
- Le ostie di Siena sono ancora incorrotte — Francesco Ognibene, Avvenire, October 23, 2014 (Italian).
This account is written in our own words from the sources above. If you know of a correction or a better source, please tell us.