What happened
In 1608 the Benedictine abbey church of Notre-Dame at Faverney, in Franche-Comté, then a Habsburg territory, drew crowds each Pentecost for a papal indulgence. On the eve of Pentecost, Saturday, May 24, the monks set up a temporary wooden altar against the iron grille that closed off the choir. On it, under a canopy, they placed a silver-gilt reliquary that served as a monstrance. It held relics said to be of St. Agatha and, in a small glass-covered case above them, two consecrated Hosts. Two lamps burned in front of it.
The church was locked after the Pentecost services. At about 3 a.m. on Monday, May 26, the sacristan, coming in to ring for Matins, found the altar burning. The table, its cloths, and most of the canopy burned, and the altar stone cracked. The monks searched the ashes for the Hosts and found nothing. Then one of them looked up and saw the monstrance beside the grille, apparently hanging in the air with nothing holding it.
It stayed there into Tuesday as crowds gathered. On Tuesday, May 27, between nine and ten in the morning, during a Mass celebrated by Nicolas Aubry, the parish priest of nearby Menoux, the monstrance came down gently onto a corporal that had been placed a few inches beneath it. The Hosts were whole. One showed a slight discoloration from smoke on the side facing the grille.
What the records show
Few such events are better documented. On May 27 the prior and monks sent a written report to the archbishop of Besançon, Ferdinand de Rye. On May 29 his council ordered an inquiry. Two officials of the archbishop’s court went to Faverney and took sworn statements from 52 witnesses, chosen from the crowds who had seen the monstrance: monks, priests, officials, and lay men and women. They closed their report on June 4.
The statements are detailed and not entirely uniform. Several witnesses said that at first the little cross on top of the monstrance seemed to touch the grille. On Monday afternoon a Capuchin, Father Vincent of Salins, examined it closely by candlelight, blew away the ash between the cross and the iron, and said there was a gap. The council’s judgment still described the cross as almost touching one of the grille’s small fittings. Witnesses added that so slight a contact could not have borne its weight.
On June 9 the archbishop’s council, joined by Dominican, Jesuit, Capuchin, and other theologians, weighed the depositions and judged the event a clear miracle. The original file was lost in the French Revolution, but four certified copies survive, and the whole dossier was published in 1908.
What the Church has said
Archbishop de Rye published a formal declaration of the miracle on July 10, 1608, as the Council of Trent required. Word went to Pope Paul V through the nuncio in Brussels, and the auxiliary bishop of Besançon sent him a formal report. At the request of Dole, then the capital of Franche-Comté, one of the two Hosts was given to that town in December 1608. The other stayed at Faverney. At the 400th anniversary in 2008, Cardinal André Vingt-Trois of Paris preached there, insisting that far too many people had seen it for it to be a hoax.
Questions that remain
The grille. The witnesses themselves debated whether the cross touched the grille. The main evidence that it did not is Father Vincent’s inspection, made by candlelight in a crowded church after ash had settled on the fittings. A skeptic will ask whether it could have rested on, or caught in, part of the grille or the burned altar without anyone seeing. The witnesses and the council considered this and rejected it, but no one can re-examine the scene now.
Who investigated. The inquiry was run by the archbishop’s own officials and judged by his council, at a time of bitter conflict between Catholics and Protestants. The judgment says the miracle served to confound unbelievers and heretics, and a Huguenot who saw it wrote an account of his conversion. That does not make the witnesses unreliable, but a historian has to keep it in mind.
The surviving Host. During the Revolution, members of the town council seized the Faverney Host, mocked it, and kept it in a sealed box before it was returned to the church. Its continuity rests on a sworn statement made in 1840 by a former lay brother of the abbey, then 88. We could not confirm what became of the Host given to Dole.
What believers point to. Fifty-two sworn witnesses, questioned within two weeks, with their doubts recorded alongside their certainties, make Faverney unusual among reported miracles. Crowds watched it for more than a day (tradition says 33 hours), and thousands were in the church when it came down.
Visiting today
The former abbey church, now the Basilica of Notre-Dame, stands in the village of Faverney in the Haute-Saône department, near Vesoul. Its northeast chapel is now the Chapel of the Miracle of the Holy Hosts, and a 1975 window shows the monstrance amid the flames.
Sources and further reading
- Le miracle des saintes hosties conservées dans les flammes à Faverney, en 1608: notes et documents — Besançon: Jacquin, 1908 (French). Public domain. Prints the 1608 inquiry with all 52 depositions, the council's judgment, the archbishop's declaration, and related documents, from the surviving certified copies.
- Homélie du cardinal André Vingt-Trois: Célébration du 4e centenaire du Miracle de Faverney — Archdiocese of Paris, May 25, 2008 (French). Homily at Faverney for the 400th anniversary.
- Église abbatiale puis paroissiale, actuellement basilique Notre-Dame — Inventaire général du patrimoine culturel, Région Bourgogne-Franche-Comté, 2012–13 (French). History of the church and its Chapel of the Miracle.
This account is written in our own words from the sources above. If you know of a correction or a better source, please tell us.