I'm skeptical · Part 4

Eucharistic miracles: what was claimed, and what was found

Over the centuries, Catholics have reported consecrated hosts that seemed to turn into flesh or blood. Here are four well-known cases, what investigators reported, and the serious questions that remain.

Normally, nothing visible happens at Mass: as chapter 2 explained, the appearances of bread remain. A “Eucharistic miracle” is the reported exception, a consecrated Host or consecrated wine that visibly takes on the appearance of flesh or blood.

Two things first. The Church never requires anyone to believe in a particular miracle. Its 2024 norms for judging such reports, which explicitly mention bleeding hosts, say that even when the Vatican clears a phenomenon for devotion, “the faithful are not obliged to give an assent of faith” to it.

And Catholic belief in the Real Presence does not rest on these events. If every case below turned out to have a natural explanation, the Church’s teaching on the Eucharist would not change by a word.

Lanciano, Italy (8th century, by tradition)

The claim. According to tradition, a monk saying Mass in Lanciano doubted the Real Presence. As he spoke the words of consecration, the Host turned into flesh and the wine into blood, which clotted into five small pellets. The relics are displayed there today.

What was found. In 1970–71, with Church authorization, Professor Odoardo Linoli, head of the clinical laboratory at the hospital in Arezzo, took and examined samples, consulting the Siena anatomist Ruggero Bertelli. Linoli reported human heart muscle and human blood, both of blood group AB, with no trace of preservatives. He published his findings in 1971 in an Italian clinical journal, Quaderni Sclavo di Diagnostica.

Questions that remain. The earliest surviving written accounts come centuries after the event, and the relics have never been radiocarbon-dated. Critics note the very small team, and that blood-typing old, degraded material is unreliable; some bacteria react like the A and B blood-group markers. A widely repeated claim that the World Health Organization confirmed the findings appears to be unfounded: researchers who checked found no record of any such WHO investigation.

Buenos Aires, Argentina (1992–1996)

The claim. At the parish of Santa María, blood-like substances were reported in 1992 and 1994. In August 1996, a discarded consecrated Host was placed in water in the tabernacle to dissolve, as is normal practice. Days later it appeared to have become a reddish substance resembling flesh. The auxiliary bishop, Jorge Mario Bergoglio (later Pope Francis), had it photographed.

What was found. From 1999, with the archdiocese’s permission, an investigation coordinated by Ricardo Castañón Gómez sent samples to several laboratories. The best-known result came in the mid-2000s from Dr. Frederick Zugibe, a forensic pathologist and longtime chief medical examiner of Rockland County, New York, who reportedly was not told where the sample came from. He described heart muscle from the left ventricle, inflamed and containing white blood cells.

Questions that remain. The Host sat in water for about three years before testing, and samples passed through several hands. The results are known mainly from the investigators’ own presentations and from Catholic media, and attempts to obtain a human DNA profile reportedly failed. As far as we can find, the archdiocese has never formally declared the event a miracle; a 2024 decree regulates devotion to the relic without ruling on it.

Sokółka, Poland (2008)

The claim. On October 12, 2008, at St. Anthony’s Church in Sokółka, a Host fell to the floor during Communion and was placed in water to dissolve. A week later, the sacristan noticed a red spot on it.

What was found. In January 2009, two pathologists at the Medical University of Białystok, Maria Sobaniec-Łotowska and Stanisław Sulkowski, examined a sample separately. Both concluded it most closely resembled heart muscle, apparently interwoven with the fibers of the bread. In October 2009 the Archdiocese of Białystok said the event did not contradict the Church’s faith but rather confirmed it: careful language, short of a formal miracle declaration. Since 2011 the Host has been displayed for veneration.

Questions that remain. The university distanced itself, saying it had not commissioned the study and that tissue analysis alone could not establish the material’s origin without genetic testing. No DNA analysis has been made public, and the archbishop reportedly declined offers of further testing.

Legnica, Poland (2013)

The claim. On Christmas Day 2013, at St. Hyacinth’s Church in Legnica, a Host fell during Communion, was placed in water, and soon developed a red discoloration.

What was found. After an inconclusive first round of tests in 2014, a department of forensic medicine in Szczecin reported fragments of striated muscle “most similar to the heart muscle,” with signs of distress, and said genetic testing pointed to human origin. After consulting the Vatican’s Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, Bishop Zbigniew Kiernikowski announced in April 2016 that the Host “has the hallmarks of a Eucharistic miracle” and authorized its veneration.

Questions that remain. The first laboratory, in Wrocław, saw fungal threads around the fibers and found no DNA. The second laboratory was brought in after the diocesan commission found that first answer unsatisfactory. And the head of the Szczecin department himself cautioned that a sample like this passes through many hands and is easily contaminated, including with human DNA.

What a fair-minded skeptic will notice

  • Who commissioned the studies. Each was commissioned or authorized by Church authorities, or done by researchers sympathetic to the claim.
  • Where the results appeared. None of these findings has been published and independently replicated in a major peer-reviewed scientific journal.
  • Chain of custody. Hosts sat in water for days, weeks, or years, passed through many hands, and were sampled under conditions that would not satisfy a forensic lab today.
  • Contamination. Red growth on damp bread has well-known natural causes. In 1819 the Italian scientist Bartolomeo Bizio traced a scare over “bloody” polenta near Padua to a red-pigmented bacterium now called Serratia marcescens. Some of the strongest recent cautions have come from Catholic scientists themselves. In a 2024 study, ordinary unconsecrated wafers left in water sometimes developed red growths of fungi and bacteria, and a 2025 Polish study of 25 discolored Hosts found no real evidence of human blood in any of them.

A fair-minded believer would add that some examiners worked without knowing what they were looking at, and that separate laboratories reported similar results. Fair enough, but neither point settles the question.

Why this can’t settle it, either way

If you hoped for laboratory proof of the Real Presence, we have to disappoint you. These cases are, at most, intriguing and contested.

There is also a deeper reason. Even a Host that really became heart tissue would show a change in the appearances: a sign. The Real Presence is a claim about what lies beneath the appearances of every consecrated Host, including the millions that look like nothing but bread. No microscope could confirm or refute that.

As Jesus told Thomas, “Blessed are those who have not seen and have believed” (John 20:29).

Going further

Scripture quotations are from the World English Bible (public domain) unless otherwise noted. References marked “CCC” are to the Catechism of the Catholic Church.